The Top 3 Companies for Comprehensive Car Insurance

FREE Car Insurance Comparison

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Compare quotes from the top car insurance companies and save!

Key takeaways...
  • If you’re looking for comprehensive coverage, there are companies that specialize in that type of auto insurance
  • The top three companies for comprehensive coverage are: State Farm, Geico, and Allstate
  • Each company has its perks as well, ranging from multiple coverage options and policy modifications to excellent customer service and communication skills

When it comes to selecting car insurance, customers need as much information as possible like premium amounts, deductibles, and especially coverage options.

These crucial facets help customers make informed decisions and worthwhile investments. While auto insurance is mandatory, comprehensive coverage offers broad protection for drivers across the board.

Comprehensive coverage includes repairs and replacement of vehicles that have been damaged by fires or floods. Cars are also protected in cases of theft and vandalism.

While each car insurance policy differs, there are companies that specialize in comprehensive insurance coverage for new or existing drivers.

Use our comparison tool for FREE car insurance quotes by entering your ZIP code above!

Table of Contents

State Farm

image source

image source

State Farm is an industry leader in automobile insurance coverage.

With several types of coverage available, the company is heralded for their knowledge and professionalism. Whether it’s browsing quotes or filing claims, State Farm representatives are always available to help customers 24/7.

For more detailed information on this company, head over to our State Farm Review.

While they feature auto liability coverage and personal injury protection (PIP), they also offer one of the top comprehensive insurance plans on the market today.

This type of coverage helps pay for loss or damage to insured vehicles, which are not caused by vehicle rollovers or accidents.  Examples include:

  • Wind
  • Hail
  • Fire
  • Floods
  • Theft
  • Vandalism
  • Hitting animals on the road

FREE Car Insurance Comparison

Compare quotes from the top car insurance companies and save!

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Since most of these are natural causes, drivers are not responsible for damages assessed. Still, they must pay monthly premiums to meet certain deductibles.

Monthly payments are the only way to secure protection and coverage for all vehicles involved.

When looking for the right type of comprehensive coverage, there are three aspects to keep in mind:

  • Comprehensive coverage only protects insured cars that were damaged in non-accident situations
  • Non-accident situations include theft, vandalism, and especially natural disasters like floods, wind damage, fire, hail, etc.
  • Comprehensive coverage cannot protect insured vehicles that have rolled over or have been involved in extensive accidents


In addition to State Farm, Geico is a nationally renowned company known for top comprehensive coverage. While comprehensive coverage is not mandatory, Geico recommends this insurance for cars that are currently financed or leased.

Also, drivers have to meet their deductibles before the company can pay for repairs or damages to insured vehicles. The higher the deductible is, the lower your monthly premium payments will be.

Like other comprehensive coverage specialists, Geico lists each coverage option in great detail to prevent any miscommunication between the customer and company.

Geico offers comprehensive coverage under their “Acts of God” category and protects insured drivers from:

  • Windstorms
  • Hail and gust
  • Hurricanes and tornadoes
  • Fires, smoke, and ash
  • Theft and vandalism
  • Hitting a deer or other animal on the road

Drivers are also protected regardless if it was their fault or the fault of an unknown party or driver. Geico also reiterates the following points for anyone that needs comprehensive coverage.

  • Comprehensive insurance is not mandatory
  • Coverage is only extended to vehicles that have been damaged in “Act of God” situations
  • Drivers can purchase additional insurance, such as collision to coincide with their current policies


image source

image source

No comprehensive coverage list is complete without Allstate. As one of the nation’s oldest and most respected insurance companies, they offer a vast selection of auto insurance options and choices.

Allstate lists comprehensive coverage options at their site for optimal convenience. Customers can also speak to agents about policy modifications, as well as adding comprehensive coverage to existing plans.

Do more research on Allstate and read this review on Allstate car insurance.

Allstate deductible options also range from $0 to well over $1,000 for insured drivers.

In addition to the items mentioned above, comprehensive insurance also covers:

  • Broken windshields or shattered windows
  • Falling objects like rocks, stone, and gravel
  • Earthquakes

There are many reasons to purchase comprehensive car insurance. While this type of coverage can be dropped at any time, it is vital to have within the first year of buying a car.

If you’re looking for better and more affordable comprehensive coverage, enter your ZIP code below and compare at least three to four policies today!

FREE Car Insurance Comparison

Compare quotes from the top car insurance companies and save!

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption