Jessica Sautter is a Content Writer for with a Bachelor’s Degree from Eastern Michigan University in Elementary Education with a Major in Reading and a Minor in Mathematics.

Full Bio →

Written by

Chris Harrigan has an economic degree from Limestone College and an MBA from Clemson University. He previously managed auto insurance claims for Enterprise Rent-A-Car. Currently, he is using his business and insurance expertise to provide insurance data analysis and visualizations to enhance the user experience.

Full Bio →

Reviewed by Chris Harrigan
Former Auto Insurance Claims Manager

UPDATED: Sep 10, 2020

Advertiser Disclosure

It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right car insurance coverage choices.

Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident car insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We are not affiliated with any one car insurance company and cannot guarantee quotes from any single company.

Our car insurance industry partnerships don’t influence our content. Our opinions are our own. To compare quotes from many different car insurance companies please enter your ZIP code on this page to use the free quote tool. The more quotes you compare, the more chances to save.

Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about auto insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything auto insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by auto insurance experts.

Buying car insurance from the top 10 car insurance companies in South Dakota can have certain advantages. For a company to be ranked among the top ten, it has to beat all others in a number of aspects.

These include product package, customer experience, rates, bonuses and financial reliability among others. However, not all top insurance companies provide all these.

The only way to find out whether these advantages apply to the company you choose is by comparing quotes.

Top 10 North Dakota Car Insurance Companies

If you are in South Dakota, these are the top companies whose quotes you should compare:

  1. Nationwide
  2. Allstate
  3. State Farm
  4. Farmers
  5. MetLife Auto & Home
  6. Hartford Group
  7. Liberty Mutual
  8. Safeco
  10. Zurich N/America

A lot of car owners wrongly assume that if the company is offering cheap car insurance rates, it must compromise on quality. Another wrong assumption is that companies that are well known automatically provide high quality services.

All these are myths, as the opposite can be true with any given company where the above are concerned. You will only find out what a company’s inner workings are like if you compare affordable auto insurance offers as given by the various companies. Enter your ZIP code above to get started!

Qualities of a Top Auto Insurance Company

In most states around the country, the number of car insurance companies ranges between 70 and 100 or more. This is a big number for anyone to sort through.

Granted, only a percentage of these companies provide above par services and prices. Just what does it take for a company to make it to the top in an industry teeming with hundreds of players?

Here are some of the qualities of a top insurance company:

  • They are financially stable
  • They are reliable and trustworthy
  • They have excellent customer service
  • They offer affordable rates
  • They package their products in an attractive and practical way
  • Each of their policy comes with guaranteed bonuses
  • They have flexible payment options
  • Their terms and conditions are friendly.

Financial Stability

A company that is financially stable is one that is likely to remain in business for a long time to come. In the car insurance business, this is very important, as it gives reassurance to the customer that their welfare is taken care of.

Companies with a poor financial standing can collapse at any time, leaving customers in loss.

It is always important to check whether the insurance company has reinsurance before buying a policy from them. Thankfully, many states require licensed and operational insurance companies to have reinsurance.

Check whether auto insurance is included in the reinsurer’s cover. If the company is not willing to provide details of their reinsurer, you should be worried. When they give you details of reinsurance, try and confirm all the major points to ensure that there are no loose ends.


Top 10 Car Insurance Companies in North Dakota

Top car insurance companies have built a good reputation over the years. They have nothing to hide about their operations and will lay out the deal in black and white when you show interest.

None reliable companies will have vague clauses in their policies, which might work against you in the event that you file a claim.

When considering a company’s trustworthiness, do a background check to find out how stable their rates are and whether there is any untoward conduct recorded in their operations.

It is also important to confirm that the company is registered with the Department of Insurance in your state and licensed to operate in the state.

Customer Service

It might surprise you to know that some big companies provide poor customer support. The best way to test the insurer you are considering signing up with is by placing a call to them vey late at night, in the morning or on non-working days.

If the phone goes unanswered, that is a warning sign. Your enticing insurance provider will not be there when you crash into someone’s car at midnight on New Year’s Eve!


It is not enough to provide excellent service and products when no one can afford it. Top car insurance companies know how to balance the two so they have great quality products and services without leaving the customer broke. If you have to get a loan to buy the insurance, reconsider the purchase.

After all, there are monthly or bimonthly premiums, depending on the payment options, that you will need to pay. A good policy is one you can pay for without struggling.

Well-Packaged Products

Top insurance companies know the impact of presenting well-packaged products to their customers. They do not sell generic policies; rather, they customize their policies to cater for specific client needs, making each customer feel special.

If the provider does not provide customization options for you, you may want to keep looking until you find one who does. This is because no two drivers have the exact same insurance needs, even though they may be of the same age, gender and drive the same car model.


This is a big one for any motorist. If you have ever had to hire a taxi because you had no way of getting home after your car stalled, you understand how much difference road assistance and rentals can provide.

Additional services you may find crucial are towing and tyre service. Ask the insurer whether these services are inclusive in the package or you would have to pay extra for them.

Comparing offers between companies will help you find out whether Company A is charging a lot for extras when Company B is offering the same at no extra cost or at minimal cost.

Payment Options

Top insurance companies provide various payment options for the customer to choose from. In this category are the policy term, number of premiums throughout the policy term and choice of deductible amount.

A good company allows customers to pay their premiums in one go or divide them into manageable amounts over a given period. They are also flexible with the deductible amounts, allowing the customer to raise the amount to the highest they are comfortable paying.

Terms and Conditions

North Dakota's Top 10 Car Insurance CompaniesTop insurance companies make their terms and conditions clear right from the start.

There are no hidden charges that you only find out about after you have made a claim.

If something is unclear in their policy, they invite questions and provide clarity. Their staff is knowledgeable about all their policies and will provide in-depth answers.

If the company does not provide clear answers or explanations to questions you ask, take that as a bad sign and take off. Make sure you find the right company with our FREE quote comparison tool!

So how can you make sure that the company you plan to buy the policy from has all the above qualities? By comparing quotes; it helps you see each company’s offer against the competitors’, making it easy to make a decision. Start today with our FREE ZIP code search tool!